not me..

Reminds me a lot of the iLife '05 cover: http://goyaboy.org/blog/images/ilife.gif

Really cool, it does remind me of the iLife cover as well. Well done.

this is pretty lame, sorry.

I like it. Simple.

Reminds me of iLife 05.

It is meaningless,
I've just done this wallpaper to be visually pleasant ;)
Nothing more to see in it :)

wow why are people so mean? i was just going to say i love it. similar to ilife or not. it's just a desktop picture people, why do you feel the need to diss it?

what is this?

I love this...yes it is simple...and yes it might look a little bit like iLife 05, but I think it is great. I love seeing more vector stuff on here...and the green is awesome! It's been my desktop since Monday and I have no intention of taking it down any time soon!

idk, i like it a lot. it also reminds me of the iLife cover as everyone else, but i don't think it's crap at all! don't ever let the crap comments get you down - i've been there and it's not fun, but maybe the fact that people are commenting saying they like it (like me) will help you feel better! remember that people like andre_afonso01 majorly need to get lives. i'd like to see people like that make something like this! :P good job and keep it up. i'd like to see more of your work!

Aqua*star...
DID YOU KNOW THAT...
"What is this?" <<< means I DONT LIKE IT!
and it seems that im not the only one...

Making something like this its soo easy that i bet anyone where could do better in microsoft paint in a matter of 5 minutes.

Only babies like you get down by reading comments of people who dont like your recent artwork ... bah! Grow up!

END OF DISCUSSION

I like it very much, especially how the trees are different (hemlock, palm, pine, oak-lke). I love plants and depictions of them! :-)

Some kids just don't know the value of Netiquette. What a bunch of brats.

Ignore the haters, Gribouille, I'd love to see more works of yours.

Thanks you aqua*star, MacDude, ontheroad, etc.
Reading your comments I think that I'll post some other wallpaperz :)

Grib, from France.

(sorry for anonymous posts)

i luv luv luv it!!!!!!!!!!!! its kinda like ilife............. but its also pretty different!! i luv it! submit more soon!! i wish i was that good with illustrator!!

It's cool that some people like this. However, this is a discussion forum, and I think people should be able to express dislike just the same as those who approve of it. And while it sucks that people put down comments that don't give any reason why they dislike it, there are generally speaking an equal number of comments from people that say they like it with no qualifier either and no one gets mad at them.

Personally I don't like this wallpaper. It just seems a bit boring and meaningless. It might not have an intended meaning, but that's no reason for me to like it.

I think if you spent some more time in and really made the root structure of all the trees interesting to look at you might produce a cool product. Elegant simplicity is one thing, a bunch of blobs with writing on them is another.

I've no time, just done it for fun in 15 minutes.
If you don't like, what the matter? pick another one.
This is for those who like this lame, meaningless and boring wallpaper.

Personally, I think that the symbolism of the roots/leaves is pretty good. It might be meaningless to some of you, but for instance the summer tree gives me the idea of summer pretty well. The essential is invisible to the eye.

Keep up the good job.

nice job !